Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Tools
-Getting Started
-Policies
-Formatting Tips
-Public Schools
-Classifieds
-Dedham News
-E-mail Us


Social Media

 Subscribe in a reader

--Twitter accounts--
--@myDedham--
--@DedhamHistory--

--Twitter lists--
--Dedhamites on Twitter--
--Dedham Organizations--
--Dedham Businesses--

Links
Official Links
  • Town's Website
  • Town Charter
  • Assessor's database
  • CodeRED
  • Commission on Disability
  • Public Schools
  • -Norfolk Aggie
  • -Blue Hills
  • Public Library
  • Police
  • Water District
    Community Groups
  • DHS Alumni
  • DHS Alumni on LinkedIn
  • Choral Society
  • Civic Pride
  • Community House
  • Cub Scouts
  • Education Foundation
  • Educational Partnership
  • Food Pantry
  • Friends of the Library
  • Historical Society
  • Horse Thieves Society
  • Fairbanks House
  • Food Pantry
  • Junior Women's Club
  • Moose
  • Mother Brook Community Group
  • Museum of Bad Art
  • Retired Mens Club
  • Rotary Club
  • Square Circle
    Government
  • US Sen. Kerry
  • US Sen. Brown
  • US Rep. Lynch
  • MA Sen. Walsh
  • MA Rep. McMurtry
  • Town Administrator
  • --TA's Weekly Updates
  • Town Boards
  • Town Clerk
  • Cultural Council
    Local Sports
  • Youth Baseball
  • Youth Hockey
  • Pop Warner
  • Youth Soccer
  • Softball
  • Lacrosse
  • Girls Basketball
  • CYO Basketball
    Dedham News
  • Your Town - Dedham
  • Dedham Transcript
  • Google News
    Churches
  • Adventist
  • Allin Congregational UCC
  • Calvary Baptist
  • First Church UU
  • Fellowship Bible
  • Good Shepard Episcopal
  • St John's Orthodox
  • St. Luke's Lutheran
  • St. Mary's Catholic
  • St. Mary's LifeTeen
  • St. Paul's Episcopal
  • St. Susanna's Catholic
    Other
  • Blogs
  • --Dedham Rocks
  • --Dedham Tales
  • Books
  • The Box Office
  • Dedham Pottery
  • Public Television
  • Real Estate Blog
  • Universal Hub
  • Videos
  • Wikipedia

  • Search




    Advanced Search


    Brian Keaney

    The School Committee doesn't like it when you smile

    by: Brian

    Thu Aug 27, 2009 at 00:18:41 AM EDT


    Note: This originally began as a comment in reply to DYNAYH's question about how my requests for public documents have gone, but it got so long I decided to make it a post of it's own.

    This isn't directly related to my requests for information, but I think it illustrates just how bad things have gotten.  At one point during the School Committee meeting tonight Chairman Dave Roberts demanded to know why I was smiling.  I kid you not, he found the involuntary curling of my lips objectionable.  I haven't seen the replay on TV yet, but I honestly didn't even know I was smiling until he pointed it out.  

    I was standing at the podium, trying to pose the same question Joanne Flately asked of the Special Education subcommittee several months ago.  Here is the exchange, and here is an MP3 recording of it:


    DR: This is not a subject we are going to discuss at this time, Brian.

    BK: Is there any time in which you will discuss it?

    DR: I'm not sure, Brian.  I don't have an answer for you right now.

    BK: But I....

    DR: Why are you smiling, Brian?!

    BK: Why am I smiling?  It's because I think it's somewhat humorous that I've tried several times to ask questions about this topic and it never seems to be the time, Mr Chairman.  Now you are telling me that you don't know if there will ever be a time.  

    To Dave's credit, there was another woman in the audience who tried to shout me down while I was at the podium, and he cut her right off.  That could have gotten ugly fast.

    Brian :: The School Committee doesn't like it when you smile
    As crazy as that was (and believe me, I did more than smile after it was over - I've already gotten phone calls and laughed with people about it), it wasn't the worst part of the night.  

    For reasons unknown, June Doe's secretary refuses to share a table with me.  Usually in the conference room there are two folding tables set off the side.  For every single meeting that is held in that room I use one of them to put my laptop on.  It has never, ever, not even once been an issue with any other Committee.  For a few meetings towards the end of the last school year it almost became a race to see who got there first.  

    If I got there first she would squeeze in with the Committee.  If she got there first she would put up reserved signs on the table, despite the fact that neither she nor I needed even 50% of it.  I've shared it with other reporters before, and there has always been plenty of room.

    For the past several meetings they have instructed the janitors at Town Hall to lock up those two tables in a closet before I get there so that I can't use them.  You may be asking yourself what does Mary Gormley, June's secretary, use if both tables are put away and locked up, and a very good question it would be.  

    They have begun bringing their own folding table for her to use.  They are now literally going out of their way, trudging back and forth from the High School to Town Hall with their own table, just to make my life more difficult.  I'm honestly not sure if it is done out of pettiness or spite.  Of course, this now presents a new problem in that she sets up next to the power outlet.  So, when I want to plug in my laptop I am forced to sit behind her, which she also finds intolerable.  All this just so she won't have to sit at the same table as me.

    I really, really, don't want it to be like this.  I like most people, and I hope most people like me.  I find it is much easier and pleasanter to go through life when interactions with others are congenial.  While I won't back down, I don't like confrontations and I try to avoid them whenever possible.  It seems to me that we've been through this whole table business enough that it is almost scripted, and a confrontation is inevitable.  

    I have honestly pondered the thought that maybe it is me.  Maybe I am the problem.  I don't blame Mary for being upset about all the extra work she has to do responding to my requests for public records, but when it's not a problem for a single other committee then I tend to conclude that it's not me after all.  If it is, if she would only tell me what it is she finds so disagreeable about sitting with me, then I will work to correct it.  I'll shower before meetings if I smell, I'll brush my teeth again, I'll stop tapping my notebook with my pen if that's the problem.  

    It's gone beyond absurd when I'm getting yelled at for smiling.  There has to be a better way.  I'm willing to do my part, but I can't do it alone.  

    Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
    Print Friendly View Send As Email

    | More
    ad nauseum (0.00 / 0)
    What was the question(s) you asked prior to "the exchange"?

    DR: This is not a subject we are going to discuss at this time, Brian.
    BK: Is there any time in which you will discuss it?

    DR: I'm not sure, Brian.  I don't have an answer for you right now.

    BK: But I....

    DR: Why are you smiling, Brian?!

    BK: Why am I smiling?  It's because I think it's somewhat humorous that I've tried several times to ask questions about this topic and it never seems to be the time, Mr Chairman.  Now you are telling me that you don't know if there will ever be a time.

    and

    re: secretary

    Maybe I am the problem
     Yes.

    The question (0.00 / 0)
    The question I tried to ask before the exchange is the same question that Joanne Flatley herself asked of the Special Education Subcommittee in April.  She said, "I'd like to know... how the hell it got in the Globe."  You can listen for yourself on myDedhamNews.

    Dave cut me off several times when I tried to ask that same question, and eventually I got out "This parent wanted to know how," when Dave started speaking over me, and said that parent should come back and ask the question again if she wanted an answer.  I told him I was interested as well, and Dave told me that we wouldn't be going any further with that line of questioning.  Apparently Joanne is allowed to ask the question twice, but I am not allowed to ask it once.  

    Dave keeps insisting that my questions would be about confidential matters and that is why he won't allow me to ask them, though over several meetings he has cut me off before I've ever gotten them out.  I have never tried to ask any question that would probe the confidential matters of any student.  My questions at the meetings have always been about decisions and actions of School Department staff, never students.

    Perhaps the most frustrating part of my whole time at the podium was at the end when Dave wouldn't let me ask any question, generic or specific, about the academic tutoring programs offered in the schools.  "But you haven't given me a reason why," I protested.  "I don't have to give you a reason," he retorted with clear exasperation in his voice.  Not that I expected any better, but it was at that point I decided to give up for the night and sat down again.  

    Finally, 84, since you state that I am the problem, what it is about me that makes sharing a table so disagreeable?  Do I smell?  Do I have bad breath?  Do I smile too much?

    myDedham.org - a community since 1636 and online since 2007!


    [ Parent ]
    Keep smiling and digging!!! (0.00 / 0)


    [ Parent ]
    Needs more help (0.00 / 0)
    It is clear to me that Brian will not get any answers by himself;  I suggest those who feel this is an issue attend some SC meetings and voice their concern officially.  If others are not willing to do this I recommend putting this on the back burner for awhile and focusing on other issues.



    [ Parent ]
    public records (0.00 / 0)
    although this is not directly relating to the problem of smiling:), but just the difficulty and price of acquiring information, it may be of some consolation to read the article in the Globe (9/24) about requesting records: High costs can make open records seem closed.

    One comment that sums it up:

    Average citizens and professional reporters say public agencies have shown an increasing propensity to flout the state's public records law by engaging in long delays or by charging exorbitant fees.


    My takeaway (0.00 / 0)
    I read that piece also, and if had to cull out a quote that summed up my experience, it would be this from Joe Bergantino:

    "It's clearly a way of saying, 'We're going to make this as difficult as possible for you, and we'd like you to just go away,' '' Bergantino said.


    myDedham.org - a community since 1636 and online since 2007!

    [ Parent ]
    i hear ya (0.00 / 0)
    yeah, they didn't really go into the part where people start treating you like crap and taking away the furniture and the rest of it...

    [ Parent ]

    HOME

    All content © 2010
    The Contentment Company

    Creative Commons License


    Event Calendar
    September 2010
    (view month)
    S M T W R F S
    * * * 01 02 03 04
    05 06 07 08 09 10 11
    12 13 14 15 16 17 18
    19 20 21 22 23 24 25
    26 27 28 29 30 * *
    << (add event) >>

    Poll
    Legacy Place has been around for a year now. How do you like it?
    Great! I go there all the time.
    Good. I'm glad we have it, but I don't go often.
    It's OK. Doesn't affect me one way or another.
    Bad. It's been a net-negative for the town.
    Terrible! I wish they never built it.

    Results

    Active Users
    Currently 0 user(s) logged on.


    Powered by: SoapBlox